The Abolition of Man | AIER

Reprinted from the Unbiased Institute

A buddy inspired me to learn The Abolition of Man by C.S. Lewis (1898–1963). Right here comply with passages from it. The e-book may be very quick. It was printed in 1943. Nationwide Overview ranked it seventh of the 100 Finest Non-Fiction Books of the twentieth century. The Intercollegiate Research Institute ranked it 2nd of one of the best books of the twentieth century. David Theroux has written a worthwhile essay exhibiting that Lewis opposed the governmentalization of social affairs.

In 4 of the quotations, Lewis speaks of “the Tao.” By that he means one thing just like the universe, together with its ethical order, or maybe the notion of a morally ordered universe. In a single citation he speaks of “The Inexperienced E-book,” that means The Management of Language: A Crucial Method to Studying and Writing, by Alexander King and Martin Ketley, printed in 1939; Lewis hated the e-book, which was utilized in British faculties. Every citation is adopted by a web page quotation to the Signature Classics presentation of The Abolition of Man.

* * *

“The proper defence in opposition to false sentiments is to inculcate simply sentiments. By ravenous the sensibility of our pupils we solely make them simpler prey to the propagandist when he comes.” (699)

“St Augustine defines advantage as ordo amoris, the ordinate situation of the affections by which each object is accorded that form of diploma of affection which is acceptable to it. Aristotle says that the intention of schooling is to make the pupil like and dislike what he ought. When the age for reflective thought comes, the pupil who has been thus educated in ‘ordinate affections’ or ‘simply sentiments’ will simply discover the primary rules in Ethics; however to the corrupt man they may by no means be seen in any respect and he could make no progress in that science.” (700)

“The top guidelines the stomach via the chest—the seat, as Alanus tells us, of Magnanimity, of feelings organized by educated behavior into secure sentiments. The Chest-Magnanimity-Sentiment—these are the indispensable liaison officers between cerebral man and visceral man.” (704)

“The operation of The Inexperienced E-book and its variety is to supply what could also be known as Males with out Chests.” (704)

“It’s not extra of thought however defect of fertile and beneficiant emotion that marks them out. Their heads aren’t any greater than the bizarre: it’s the atrophy of the chest beneath that makes them appear so.” (704)

“And on a regular basis—such is the tragi-comedy of our state of affairs—we proceed to clamour for these very qualities we’re rendering unimaginable. You’ll be able to hardly open a periodical with out coming throughout the assertion that what our civilization wants is extra ‘drive’, or dynamism, or self-sacrifice, or ‘creativity’. In a form of ghastly simplicity we take away the organ and demand the operate. We make males with out chests and anticipate of them advantage and enterprise. We chuckle at honour and are shocked to seek out traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.” (704)

“Their scepticism about values is on the floor: it’s to be used on different individuals’s values; concerning the values present in their very own set they aren’t practically sceptical sufficient. And this phenomenon may be very regular. An ideal lots of those that ‘debunk’ conventional or (as they’d say) ‘sentimental’ values have within the background values of their very own which they imagine to be immune from the debunking course of.” (706)

“The revolt of latest ideologies in opposition to the Tao is a revolt of the branches in opposition to the tree: if the rebels might succeed they’d discover that that they had destroyed themselves.” (714)

“Aristotle mentioned that solely those that have been nicely introduced up can usefully examine ethics: to the corrupted man, the person who stands outdoors the Tao, the very place to begin of this science is invisible. He could also be hostile, however he can’t be vital: he doesn’t know what’s being mentioned.” (715)

“With the intention to keep away from misunderstanding, I could add that although I personally am a Theist, and certainly a Christian, I’m not right here trying any oblique argument for Theism. I’m merely arguing that if we’re to have values in any respect we should settle for the last word platitudes of Sensible Cause as having absolute validity: that any try, having change into sceptical about these, to reintroduce worth decrease down on some supposedly extra ‘sensible’ foundation, is doomed. Whether or not this place implies a supernatural origin for the Tao is a query I’m not right here involved with.” (716)

“For the ability of Man to make himself what he pleases means, as we’ve seen, the ability of some males to make different males what they please.” (721)

“[T]he man-moulders of the brand new age will probably be armed with the powers of an omnicompetent state and an irresistible scientific approach: we will get ultimately a race of conditioners who actually can lower out all posterity in what form they please.” (721)

“The last word springs of human motion are now not, for them, one thing given. They’ve surrendered—like electrical energy: it’s the operate of the Conditioners to manage, to not obey them. They know the way to produce conscience and determine what sort of conscience they may produce. They themselves are outdoors, above.” (722)

“‘Good’ and ‘dangerous’, utilized to them, are phrases with out content material: for it’s from them that the content material of those phrases is henceforward to be derived.” (722–723)

“Each motive they attempt to act on turns into without delay petitio. It’s not that they’re dangerous males. They aren’t males in any respect. Stepping outdoors the Tao, they’ve stepped into the void. Nor are their topics essentially sad males. They aren’t males in any respect: they’re artefacts. Man’s closing conquest has proved to be the abolition of Man.” (723)

“For the time being, then, of Man’s victory over Nature, we discover the entire human race subjected to some particular person males, and people people subjected to that in themselves which is solely ‘pure’—to their irrational impulses. Nature, untrammelled by values, guidelines the Conditioners and, via them, all humanity. Man’s conquest of Nature seems, within the second of its consummation, to be Nature’s conquest of Man. Each victory we appeared to win has led us, step-by-step, to this conclusion. All Nature’s obvious reverses have been however tactical withdrawals.” (724)

“[A]nd if the eugenics are environment friendly sufficient there will probably be no second revolt, however all cosy beneath the Conditioners…” (725)

“However as soon as our souls, that’s, ourselves, have been given up, the ability thus conferred is not going to belong to us. We will the truth is be the slaves and puppets of that to which we’ve given our souls. It’s in Man’s energy to deal with himself as a mere ‘pure object’ and his personal judgements of worth as uncooked materials for scientific manipulation to change at will. The objection to his doing so doesn’t lie in the truth that this viewpoint (like one’s first day in a dissecting room) is painful and stunning until we develop used to it. The ache and the shock are at most a warning and a symptom. The true objection is that if man chooses to deal with himself as uncooked materials, uncooked materials he will probably be: not uncooked materials to be manipulated, as he fondly imagined, by himself, however by mere urge for food, that’s, mere Nature, within the individual of his de-humanized Conditioners.” (726)

“I’m not right here pondering solely, maybe not even mainly, of those that are our public enemies in the intervening time. The method which, if not checked, will abolish Man goes on apace amongst Communists and Democrats at least amongst Fascists.” (727)

“What’s now frequent to all males is a mere summary common, an H.C.F. [highest common factor], and Man’s conquest of himself means merely the rule of the Conditioners over the conditioned human materials, the world of post-humanity which, some knowingly and a few unknowingly, practically all males in all nations are at current labouring to supply.” (727-728)

“There was little or no magic within the Center Ages: the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries are the excessive midday of magic. The intense magical endeavour and the intense scientific endeavour are twins: one was sickly and died, the opposite sturdy and throve. However they had been twins. They had been born of the identical impulse.” (728)

“In the identical spirit Bacon condemns those that worth data as an finish in itself: this, for him, is to make use of as a mistress for pleasure what should be a partner for fruit. The true object is to increase Man’s energy to the efficiency of all issues potential. He rejects magic as a result of it doesn’t work; however his purpose is that of the magician.” (729)

“You can’t go on seeing via issues for ever. The entire level of seeing via one thing is to see one thing via it. It’s good that the window ought to be clear, as a result of the road or backyard past it’s opaque. How should you noticed via the backyard too? It’s no use making an attempt to ‘see via’ first rules. If you happen to see via every part, then every part is clear. However a completely clear world is an invisible world. To ‘see via’ all issues is similar as to not see.” (730)